Now that nominations are closed, I want to say a few things about mascots.
First off, damn the the Jaromays for taking Batman! The “5 Things About Dinh” slideshow was about 50% lies, but my love for Batman is definitely true. I was actually going to make this whole post about Batman, mostly through heavy use of Dinosaur Comics. I’ve waited for Batman to be mascot for a long time, and I even had a shirt design in my back pocket. And then Jaromay term came around and I wasn’t around to take advantage. But oh well, maybe I’ll turn my shirt design into a line shirt. Anyway, now that I’ve gotten that off my chest…
A little disclaimer before I go any further — if Batman had been a possibility, I would have been all over that like Scrooge McDuck on the Number One Dime, but since that’s not the case, I would be happy to rep Luong Class with any of the nominated mascots. The following is purely for fun, and not advocation for any mascot nominee over any other.
Like I said in a previous post, a mascot is supposed to be a living embodiment of Leadership, Friendship, and Service. That is technically the only requirement.
However, seeing as girls usually outnumber guys in pledge classes (it’s roughly 8 girls to every 5 guys in this pledge class, a clear majority), a practical consideration is that a mascot should be cute, or at least shown to have the potential for cuteness. (I like how Tracey L is advertising her nominee with the cutest version possible of Iron Man.)
And like I said in the Facebook group, the mascot should be something that can be easily put on a shirt, meaning you should be able to make it look good in about three or four colors and simple lines. (Comic book characters are great at this, because comics used to be printed in four-color dot-matrix.)
After that, I’d like our mascot to be able to beat up any other mascot. Well, any other except Batman. That would be impossible. To figure out who would win, I suggest we follow the usual mascot bracketology rules:
- Inanimate objects, e.g. colors and plants, always lose to animate objects.
- Predators beat non-predators and unarmed humans.
- Humans beat non-predators.
- Humans with weapons beat predators.
- Humans with weapons beat humans without weapons.
- Humans with superior weapons win.
- Supernatural beings and weather systems beat almost anyone.
(There were actually two more rules, but I don’t think they will ever come up, as our mascot elections do not have seeds, and I can’t see anyone nominating a preposition.)
I believe this is the most current list of nominated mascots. It is a couple of days old, so there might be some changes, but I’ll base my brackets off this list.
- Mr. Fantastic
- Pikachu
- Link
- Kirby
- Ash Ketchum
- Trogdor
- Doraemon
- Taeyang
- Avatar
- Domokun
- Olimar
- Daniel Kim
- Totoro
- Iron Man
Keeping the above rules in mind, this is how I see things going down:
EDIT: I’ve been informed that the Avatar nomination was in reference to the Nickelodeon cartoon, not the Cameron movie, and I’ve changed things accordingly.
Opening Round:
Mr. Fantastic def. Pikachu — Rule 3. Even if I were generous and bumped Pikachu to a predator, Rule 4 — Mr. Fantastic would use science gizmos to ground Pikachu’s electric attacks.
Link def. Kirby — Rule 4. Link’s silver arrows would keep Kirby out of eating range.
Trogdor def. Ash Ketchum — This one is a tough call, since Ash could use his Pokemon, but I’m going to have to fall back on Rule 7.
Doraemon def. Taeyang — This was difficult in that I wasn’t sure how to classify Ding Dong. I think he’d have to get bumped up to predator due to the potential for pulling weapons out of his pouch, and Taeyang has no weapons I know of, so this seems like a case of Rule 2.
Avatar def. Domokun — I thought about calling a Rule 7 since Domokun has been called God, but if we stick to canon, Avatar has shown that while they he prefers not to kill, the Navi are Aang is quite capable of it messing up monsters that attack him. Rule 2.
Olimar def. Daniel Kim — I was going to call Rule 5 on this, but remembered that Olimar is actually an alien, so I guess I would re-classify him as a predator based on his fighting abilities as shown in Brawl. Rule 2. (Sorry Daniel!)
Iron Man def. Totoro — Unless we go into fan art, this is clearly a case of Rule 3. Even then, I’d have to call Rule 4.
Exciting! Next, the quarter-finals:
Mr. Fantastic def. Link — This opens up the whole science vs. magic debate, but I’d have to believe that super-genius Reed Richards could nullify any magic weapons Link could have. Rule 6.
Doraemon def. Trogdor — This is a major upset for what could be a case of Rule 7, but Doraemon could have things in his pouch that would withstand against the Burninator. Modified Rule 4.
Avatar def. Olimar — This would be a massacre. The Navi could communicate with the Pikmin Aang could bend away all the Pikmin and leave Olimar weaponless, or even turn them against him, since Pikmin are basically small elementals. Modified Rule 5.
Iron Man gets a by week and promptly gets wasted on the good stuff.
In the semi-finals:
Mr. Fantastic def. Doraemon — Clearly, Mr. Fantastic could out-gizmo the great Ding Dong. Modified Rule 6.
Iron Man def. Avatar — Clever military tactics fall to repulsors. This match is suddenly a lot more interesting. Aang did fight guys in suits before, and although weak on metal bending, he could crush Tony. However, I think Iron Man would be smart enough to avoid and/or nullify Aang’s bending abilities. Satellite-based attach systems push Aang into full Avatar mode, where he goes on a mindless frenzy. Iron Man unleashes his suit’s full power and knocks Aang out just like he did with Hulk. Modified Rule 6 again.
That leaves a Marvel showdown in the Championship match!
Two geniuses with a lot of expensive toys would be quite the throw down. Mr. Fantastic is the smarter of the two, and should have better toys. However, Iron Man has the full resources of Stark Enterprises and SHIELD, so he’d have more toys. Iron Man might be hung over from his by week, putting him at an initial disadvantage. I see them slugging it out and destroying most of New York City. Then Mr. Fantastic would make something to deactivate the Iron Man suits. But in his tradition of unforeseen consequences, the device would overload and destroy the world.
Pyrrhic victory for Mr. Fantastic. Rule 6.
Anyway, I hope you enjoyed my take on things. I’m very eager to see how things actually turn out tonight. Good luck to everyone running!
Oh, and I also would have enjoyed Admiral Ackbar.